Great Find: Downtown Cocktails in Midtown

Where to find Milk & Honey–caliber cocktails in the land of the lame office party.
Description
Insider Exclusive Offer: 

It’s not that there aren’t plenty of places to get a drink in Midtown, but that the options tend toward noisy pubs, power restaurants, and a few grand hotel bars. Some of those spots are amazing, no doubt, but in a city 10 years deep into a cocktail-culture renaissance, it’s still oddly difficult to find evidence of artisanal drinks amid the office buildings.

Enter Lantern’s Keep, at the Iroquois Hotel, which offers a dimly lit intimate space with few tables, fine art on the walls, and a bartender who wears thick-rimmed glasses and a vest while muddling his mint.

The head bartender and bar manager of Lantern’s Keep, Theo Lieberman, came up to the Iroquois from the cocktail-culture epicenter, Milk and Honey, and he brought with him a slew of downtown-quality drinks. There are no flavored alcohols here, and all the ingredients are the real deal, like homemade grenadine made from fresh pomegranate juice.

The space is quieter than your typical after-work bar, and if it feels exclusive, that’s because it is. There are only 30 seats—mostly at small bistro-size tables—so if you come between 5 and 9 p.m., you’ll be best off making a reservation. And when you do secure a seat, there’s no rush. Most people sit for at least an hour and half and take their time savoring the drinks.

About those drinks: The extensive menu has a heavy Prohibition-era influence along with some more current cultural references. For instance, the McKittrick Old Fashioned was named after the fictitious hotel in which the play Sleep No More takes place. (It was fashionable to name cocktails after plays in the early 1900s, says Lieberman.) The drink contains bourbon, mole chocolate bitters, and Pedro Ximinez sherry.

Other options include the Northside Special, with dark rum and lemon juice shaken with an orange wedge and topped with club soda, and the Expat, with bourbon, lime, mint, and bitters. And, of course, there are a few favorites borrowed from Milk & Honey and Little Branch, so you can sample downtown’s greatest hits without ever venturing below 42nd Street.


Lantern’s Keep: 49 West 44th Street, 212.453.4287

View Lantern's Keep in a larger map

—Christina Garofalo
  • Ocean House
Robb NYC Guide: Boutique Hotel Escapes Picking a weekend getaway spot isn't as easy as it sounds. Nothing...
  • Avenue A Club. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Welcome to Exotic Car Heaven The Ironbound section of Newark is about as plush as its name implies...
  • Harlow. Photo by Owen Hoffmann.
Decadent Dining Returns Richie Notar is sick of casual dining. The restaurateur who managed the...
  •  Golf & Body NYC. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Manhattan’s New Golf Club Billed as a state-of-the-art urban country club, Golf & Body NYC is a...
  • Truman’s Gentlemen’s Groomers. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
The Best Shave in New York If you’re anything like us, your morning shave routine involves a...
  • Madison Fine Time. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
An Extraordinary Patek Collection Watch collectors and admirers, there’s a new must-see attraction in...
  • Freemans Bench-Made Bespoke. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Robb NYC Guide: Custom Suits Few purchases are more important to get right than a suit—and there...
  • Nat Sherman. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
The Year in Pictures One of the great things about working at Robb Report NYC is being able to...
  • Grilled scallop and uni at Neta. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
The Ramen Revolutionary Long Island native Ivan Orkin moved to Japan 10 years ago and opened 12-...
  • Auden. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Fine Dining Is Back at the Ritz It’s been nearly a year since BLT Market closed on the ground floor...
  • 1969 Mercedes-Benz 280SL
Great Find: Cooper Classic Cars When Elliot Cuker decided to open Cooper Classics Collection more than 30...
  • E. Vogel. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
A Lasting Custom Footwear Tradition Custom clothing has gotten a fashion update and broadened its base in...
  • Freemans Bench-Made Bespoke. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Freemans Goes Bespoke Freemans Sporting Club was a kind of modern-day menswear pioneer when it...
Bicycles Go Bespoke Yes, riding a bike in New York is more convenient and less dangerous than...
  • Jimmy. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Our Favorite Rooftop Bars When the temperature and humidity compete to see which can hit 100 first,...
  • Ursus Books and Prints. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Collector’s Guide: Rare Bookstores Argosy Book Store Founded in 1925, Argosy is a third-generation family-...
  • The Hideaway
The Real Montauk: 5 Classic Spots Duryea’s Lobster Deck and Seafood Market With buildings that date...
  • Leffot. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Great Find: Leffot shoes If men’s shoes were a religion, Leffot might be a temple. Actually,...
  • Bhambi’s Custom Tailors. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
NYC’s Top Tailors You know the feeling: You have some garments altered, and when you pick...
  • Croteaux Vineyards
Provence on the North Fork As you pull up to the charming, shady entrance to Croteaux Vineyards, on...
Great Find: Marjorie Eliot's Parlor Jazz Back in the days of the Harlem Renaissance, a cottage industry of private...
  • Holland & Sherry
Bespoke Everything   For 185 years, the Scottish company Holland & Sherry...
  • Delamar Greenwich Harbor
Delicious Drive Destinations La Maison Blanche, Shelter Island This breezy boutique hotel in a big...
  • Five Story
New York’s Very Own Colette New York’s most inspired new boutique came to be not out of passion...
  • Carnegie Club. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Where to Smoke Like Don Draper  It’s been long enough now that it’s hard to remember...
Great Find: Cocktail Kingdom Hidden on the fifth floor of a building on 25th Street in Chelsea is one...
The Art of Framing When the Metropolitan Museum of Art decided to celebrate its new American...
  • Booker and Dax. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Better Cocktails Through Science As director of culinary technology at the French Culinary Institute, Dave...
The Greatest Sake Selection All 150 of the sakes available at Kirakuya, a new Japanese restaurant in a...
  • Apotheke. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Chinatown's Delicious Surprises Brother and sister duo Heather and Christopher Tierney know all about how...
New York’s New Top Flight It took a luxury yacht designer to notice that while the Upstairs/...
  • Snap
Sports Bars Done Right Time was, finding a good sports bar in New York was about as easy as...
Make Your Own Power Lunch Sure, a long boozy lunch in a corner seat with a commanding view at the...
From Law Suits to Making Suits Great Jones Alley is one of those little-known slices of New York that,...
  • A.F. Rapoport Hot Buttered Rum at Joseph Leonard. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Hottest Cold-Weather Cocktails A.F. Rapoport Hot Buttered Rum at Joseph Leonard Self-proclaimed “...
  • Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare
Chef’s Table: Ultimate Off-Menu Dining You’ve been to Per Se. You did the new dining room at Le Bernardin....
The Best Haircut in New York “Three weeks,” says Takamichi Saeki. “You haven’t...
  • Peter Elliot Boots, etc. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Boots and All If there were a benevolent king of the Upper East Side, he might be Peter...
  • Culture Espresso
The Fine Art of Espresso New York’s always been a coffee town. Those blue-and-white deli cups...
  • Armando Cabral Men’s Footwear. Photo by Chelsea Curtis.
Rising Footwear Designer Armando Cabral Twenty-nine-year-old Portugal native Armando Cabral started his career as...
BYO Best of NYC Whether you bring a bottle of 1997 Opus One to the table, or a favorite...
Cocktail Cures at the Bar on Fifth Bar on Fifth mixologist Robbie Clift knows the cocktail cure for almost...